PVD vs DLC Watch Coatings: Durability, Colors and Care

PVD vs DLC Watch Coatings: Durability, Colors and Care

PVD (physical vapor deposition) is a process that coats a watch case with a very thin, hard film, usually just a few microns thick, inside a vacuum chamber. It's how most black, gold-tone, rose-tone, blue and gunmetal steel watches get their color. DLC (diamond-like carbon) is a particular type of coating, usually black, made of carbon with some of the bond structure of diamond, and it's typically harder and more scratch-resistant than common PVD colors. Both bond far better than old-style electroplating, but they're still surface layers: a hard knock can mark them, and worn coatings can't be touched up, only stripped and redone.

What is PVD?

Physical vapor deposition covers a family of vacuum coating processes. In simple terms:

  1. Cleaning: Watch parts are cleaned to a very high standard, because any residue weakens the bond.
  2. Vacuum: The parts go into a sealed chamber that is pumped down to a vacuum.
  3. Vaporizing: A solid source material, such as titanium, zirconium or chromium, is turned into vapor or plasma, often using an electric arc or by bombarding it with ions (sputtering).
  4. Reacting: Gases such as nitrogen or carbon-bearing gases are introduced so the metal vapor forms hard compounds.
  5. Depositing: The vapor condenses onto the parts atom by atom, forming a thin, dense, tightly bonded film.

"Ion plating" (IP), a term used by some brands, is a form of PVD.

Common PVD colors and what makes them

Color

Typical coating compound

Gold-tone

Titanium nitride or zirconium nitride, sometimes topped with a very thin layer of real gold

Rose / bronze tones

Titanium carbonitride or similar blends

Black / gunmetal

Titanium carbide, titanium aluminum nitride, chromium-based compounds, or DLC

Blue, green and other colors

Specialty compounds or thin interference layers

The exact recipe varies by supplier, which is one reason quality varies between brands.

What is DLC?

Diamond-like carbon is an amorphous carbon coating that contains some of the same tightly bonded carbon structure as diamond. It's:

  • Very hard, often quoted in the low thousands on the Vickers hardness scale, many times harder than stainless steel
  • Low friction, so things tend to slide off it rather than dig in
  • Usually black or dark gray, with a satin or semi-gloss look

DLC is used on engine parts, cutting tools and medical devices as well as watches. On watches it's the premium choice for black cases.

PVD vs DLC vs plating

 

Electroplating

PVD

DLC

How it's applied

Metal deposited from a liquid bath with electric current

Vapor deposited in a vacuum

Carbon deposited in a vacuum (a type of vacuum coating process)

Typical thickness

Fractions of a micron to a few microns

About 1 to 5 microns

About 1 to 5 microns

Hardness

Soft (gold) to moderate

Hard

Very hard

Scratch resistance

Low

Good

Very good

Colors

Gold, silver, chrome, nickel

Wide range

Mostly black and dark gray

Wear pattern

Wears through at edges

Edges and high points over years

Edges and high points over longer periods

Cost

Low

Moderate

Higher

A micron is one-thousandth of a millimeter. Thickness varies by supplier and process.

How thick is a PVD coating?

Very thin, usually a few microns, about a twentieth of the thickness of a human hair. That's why coatings follow every detail of the case and don't soften edges. It's also why the substrate (the steel or titanium underneath) matters so much.

The "eggshell effect": why a hard coating can still get marked

A hard coating on a softer metal behaves a little like an eggshell on a soft-boiled egg. Light scratches and scuffs don't get through. But a sharp knock dents the softer steel underneath, and the thin coating can crack or flake at that spot, showing a bright silver mark.

To reduce this, some brands harden the steel surface first and then apply the coating, so the coating has a firm foundation. See Surface-hardening treatments for steel.

How do coated watches wear over time?

  • Edges and corners such as lug tips, bezel edges and the clasp see the most rubbing and are first to show wear.
  • Bracelets wear faster than cases because links rub against each other.
  • Desk diving (resting your wrist on a laptop or desk) can slowly polish the coating at the bracelet clasp and caseback edge.
  • Hard knocks can chip the coating, showing silver steel underneath.

Some people like the honest, worn look that develops on black watches, much like a well-used tool. If you want a black watch that stays perfect, DLC over hardened steel, or a ceramic case, is the most durable option.

Can PVD or DLC be repaired?

Not by spot-touching. To renew a coating, the part has to be stripped chemically or mechanically, refinished and recoated in a vacuum chamber. Some brands offer this as a service; many independent watchmakers don't. On bracelets, it's sometimes easier to replace worn links or the whole bracelet.

Is gold PVD real gold?

Sometimes partly. Many gold-tone PVD finishes are titanium nitride or zirconium nitride, which look gold but contain no gold. Some add a very thin top layer of real gold for a warmer color. Either way, a gold PVD watch is not a solid gold watch. See Gold watches: karats, colors and alloys.

Are PVD coatings safe for skin?

The ceramic-like compounds used in PVD, such as titanium nitride, are generally very inert, and a coating can reduce how much of the underlying metal touches the skin. As the coating wears, more of the base metal is exposed. Anyone with a metal allergy should consider the base metal too. See Hypoallergenic watches.

How to care for a coated watch

  • Clean with warm water, mild soap and a soft cloth or soft brush.
  • Avoid abrasive polishes, polishing cloths with compound and scouring pads, which can wear through coatings.
  • Never try to polish out a scratch on a coated case; you'll remove the coating.
  • Take the watch off for heavy work where knocks are likely.

How to choose a coated watch

If you want...

Look for...

A black watch that stays black for years

DLC, ideally over hardened steel, or a ceramic case

A gold look without gold's price

Gold-tone PVD over stainless steel

An affordable fashion color

PVD over stainless steel

A watch that ages with character

Standard black PVD or a matte coating

To avoid coatings entirely

Uncoated steel, titanium or ceramic in your chosen color

How this applies to Vardesso

If a Vardesso model has a black, gold-tone or other colored case or bracelet, its product page will describe the finish and the metal underneath. Uncolored Vardesso cases are 316L stainless steel unless a product page says otherwise.

Questions and answers

What does PVD mean on a watch?

Physical vapor deposition: a thin, hard coating applied in a vacuum to color a watch case or bracelet.

What is a DLC watch?

A watch coated with diamond-like carbon, a very hard, usually black carbon coating.

Is DLC better than PVD?

DLC is usually harder and more scratch-resistant than common PVD coatings, but quality varies by supplier and by what's underneath.

How long does PVD last on a watch?

Often many years, depending on the coating, the base metal and how hard the watch is worn. Edges and bracelets show wear first.

Does PVD scratch?

It resists light scratches well, but a hard knock can dent the steel underneath and chip the coating.

Can you fix a scratched PVD or DLC watch?

Not by touching up. The part must be stripped and recoated, which some brands offer as a service.

Is gold PVD real gold?

Usually it's a gold-colored compound like titanium nitride, sometimes with a thin real-gold top layer. It isn't solid gold.

What is the difference between PVD and gold plating?

PVD is a hard film applied in a vacuum. Gold plating is a soft layer of gold deposited from a liquid bath. PVD is far more durable.

Is IP the same as PVD?

Ion plating is a form of PVD.

How thick is a PVD coating?

Usually a few microns, a tiny fraction of a millimeter.

Can you polish a PVD watch?

No. Polishing removes the coating. Clean it with soap, water and a soft cloth.

Are black watches durable?

It depends on the finish. DLC over hardened steel and ceramic are the most durable; standard PVD can show wear at the edges over time.

Keep reading

  • Surface-hardening treatments for steel
  • Ceramic watch cases
  • Brass and plated watch cases
  • Watch case materials explained

Sources