Titanium Watches: Grade 2 vs Grade 5 Titanium Explained

Titanium Watches: Grade 2 vs Grade 5 Titanium Explained

Titanium watch cases come in two main grades. Grade 2 is commercially pure titanium (about 99% titanium): light, extremely corrosion resistant and skin-friendly, but relatively soft, so it's usually given a matte, bead-blasted or brushed finish. Grade 5, also called Ti-6Al-4V, is an alloy of about 90% titanium, 6% aluminum and 4% vanadium. It's roughly twice as hard and two to three times as strong as Grade 2, takes a brighter polish and allows sharper detailing, but costs more to machine. Both are about 40 to 45% lighter than stainless steel.

Titanium vs stainless steel

 

316L stainless steel

Grade 2 titanium

Grade 5 titanium

Composition

Iron with chromium, nickel, molybdenum

About 99% titanium

About 90% titanium, 6% aluminum, 4% vanadium

Density

About 8.0 g/cm³

About 4.5 g/cm³

About 4.4 g/cm³

Approximate hardness (Vickers)

About 150 to 200

About 120 to 200

About 300 to 350

Tensile strength

About 500 to 700 MPa

About 350 to 450 MPa

About 900 to 1,100 MPa

Color

Bright silver-white

Darker, warmer gray

Gray, can be polished brighter

Typical finish

Polished and brushed

Bead-blasted or brushed

Brushed, polished or both

Nickel

About 10 to 14%

None

None

Corrosion resistance

Very good

Excellent

Excellent

Machining

Moderate

Difficult

More difficult

Relative cost

Baseline

Higher

Highest

Hardness and strength figures are typical ranges and vary with processing.

What is Grade 2 titanium?

Grade 2 is "commercially pure" titanium, with only small amounts of iron, oxygen, carbon and nitrogen. It's the most widely used titanium in watches, especially at affordable and mid-range prices.

Strengths:

  • Very light and comfortable
  • Outstanding corrosion resistance, even in salt water
  • No nickel, so it's well suited to sensitive skin
  • Less expensive to machine than Grade 5

Limitations:

  • Soft, so it scratches and dents more easily than Grade 5
  • Doesn't take a bright mirror polish well, so it's usually bead-blasted or brushed
  • Edges and details tend to be softer

What is Grade 5 titanium?

Grade 5, Ti-6Al-4V, is the most widely used titanium alloy in the world, found in aircraft parts, medical implants and high-end sporting goods. A closely related version, Grade 23 (Ti-6Al-4V ELI, "extra low interstitial"), has fewer impurities and is common in medical implants.

Strengths:

  • Much harder and stronger than Grade 2
  • Takes a brighter polish and holds crisp edges and bevels
  • Allows thinner, more detailed cases and bracelets
  • Better resistance to dents and scratches than Grade 2

Limitations:

  • Harder to machine, which raises cost
  • Still scratches in daily wear (it's harder than steel, not scratch-proof)
  • Polished Grade 5 is a slightly darker gray than polished steel

How do they look different?

Grade 2 has a flat, gray, almost pewter look, especially when bead-blasted. Many people love it for its understated tool-watch feel. Grade 5 can be brushed or polished to something much closer to the brightness of steel, with sharper edges, which is why brands choosing a dressier titanium watch often use Grade 5.

How light is titanium, really?

Titanium is roughly 40 to 45% lighter than steel by volume. On a watch, the difference is most dramatic with a matching bracelet: a large titanium dive watch on a titanium bracelet can weigh about half as much as the same watch in steel. On a leather or fabric strap, the difference is smaller but still noticeable.

Some people love the featherweight feel. Others find a light watch less "substantial" and prefer steel's heft. Neither is wrong.

A short history of titanium watches

  • 1970: Citizen released the X-8 Chronometer, widely recognized as the first watch with a titanium case, using titanium of about 99.6% purity. Fewer than about 2,000 were made.
  • 1975: Seiko released a professional 600 m diver in titanium, an early titanium dive watch.
  • 1980 to 1981: IWC and Porsche Design introduced a titanium chronograph, often cited as the first fully titanium watch with a matching bracelet, and a landmark for titanium in Swiss watchmaking.
  • Today: Titanium is common across price points, from affordable tool watches to luxury sports watches.

Pros and cons of titanium watches

Pros

Cons

Very light

Some people prefer a heavier watch

Excellent corrosion resistance

Grade 2 scratches easily

Nickel-free and hypoallergenic

Darker gray color than steel

Non-magnetic

More expensive to produce

Feels warmer on the skin

Harder to refinish to a mirror polish

Strong for its weight

Threads can be prone to seizing, so service takes care

Does titanium scratch easily?

Grade 2 scratches more readily than steel. Grade 5 is harder than steel and holds up better, but it will still scratch. A matte, bead-blasted finish hides marks better than a polished one. Some brands apply a surface-hardening treatment to titanium, which greatly improves scratch resistance. See Surface-hardening treatments for steel; the same idea applies to titanium.

One quirk: freshly scratched titanium can look slightly darker or grayer than the surrounding metal as its oxide layer re-forms.

Can titanium be refinished?

Yes, with care. Bead-blasted Grade 2 can be re-blasted to restore an even finish. Brushed titanium can be re-brushed. Polishing titanium, especially Grade 2, is more difficult than polishing steel, so ask a watchmaker with titanium experience.

Is titanium good for sensitive skin?

Titanium is one of the best case materials for sensitive skin because it contains no nickel. Grade 2 is especially well tolerated. Grade 5 contains small amounts of aluminum and vanadium bound in the alloy, and is used for medical implants. Anyone with a known metal allergy should still check with a doctor. See Hypoallergenic watches.

Should you choose titanium?

Choose titanium if you:

  • Want the lightest, most comfortable watch for all-day wear
  • Wear a large watch or a dive watch and want less weight
  • Have sensitive skin or a nickel allergy
  • Spend a lot of time in salt water
  • Like a matte, technical look

Choose steel if you:

  • Like a heavier, more substantial feel
  • Want a bright, polished, dressy look
  • Want a material that's easier to refinish

How this applies to Vardesso

Vardesso cases use 316L stainless steel unless a product page says otherwise. If a Vardesso model uses titanium, its product page will state the grade.

Questions and answers

What is the difference between Grade 2 and Grade 5 titanium?

Grade 2 is about 99% pure titanium: soft, light and very corrosion resistant. Grade 5 is an alloy with 6% aluminum and 4% vanadium that's much harder and stronger and polishes better.

Which is better for a watch, Grade 2 or Grade 5 titanium?

Grade 5 is harder and allows sharper, more polished designs. Grade 2 is lighter on the budget and well suited to matte tool watches. Neither is "wrong."

Is titanium lighter than steel?

Yes, about 40 to 45% lighter by volume.

Is titanium stronger than steel?

Grade 5 is stronger than 316L steel. Grade 2 is somewhat weaker than 316L but far stronger for its weight.

Does titanium scratch easily?

Grade 2 scratches more easily than steel. Grade 5 is more resistant but not scratch-proof.

Is titanium hypoallergenic?

It contains no nickel and is very well tolerated, which makes it one of the best choices for sensitive skin.

What was the first titanium watch?

The Citizen X-8 Chronometer of 1970 is widely recognized as the first watch with a titanium case.

Why are titanium watches more expensive?

Titanium is harder to machine and finish than steel, which raises production costs.

Why does titanium look darker than steel?

Titanium is naturally a darker, warmer gray, and Grade 2 is usually given a matte finish.

Is titanium magnetic?

No. Titanium is non-magnetic, though that alone doesn't protect the movement inside from magnetic fields.

Can titanium be polished?

Grade 5 can take a bright polish. Grade 2 is harder to polish well and is usually bead-blasted or brushed.

Does titanium corrode?

Practically no. Titanium is one of the most corrosion-resistant metals used in watches.

Keep reading

  • Watch case materials explained
  • Hypoallergenic watches
  • Surface-hardening treatments for steel
  • Dive watches

Sources