Positional Variance Explained: Why Watch Accuracy Changes With Position

Positional Variance Explained: Why Watch Accuracy Changes With Position

Positional variance is the way a mechanical watch's accuracy changes depending on how it is oriented: dial up, dial down or standing on one of its edges. Gravity pulls on the balance wheel differently in each position, friction at its pivots changes, and tiny imperfections in balance show up more in some positions than others. A watch might gain four seconds a day lying face-up and lose three standing crown-down. Watchmakers regulate movements across several positions to keep these differences small, and you can use them yourself to nudge a watch back on time overnight.

The six positions

Watchmakers test movements in up to six positions, with standard abbreviations:

Position

Description

Common abbreviations

Dial up

Lying flat, face up

DU, or CH (cadran haut)

Dial down

Lying flat, face down

DD, or FH (fond haut)

Crown down

Standing on edge, crown pointing down

CD, or 9H

Crown up

Standing on edge, crown pointing up

CU, or 3H

Crown left

Standing on edge, crown to the left

CL, or 6H

Crown right

Standing on edge, crown to the right

CR, or 12H

The two flat positions are called horizontal; the four edge positions are called vertical. Different testing systems name the vertical positions by which hour marker points up, so the abbreviations vary. What matters is that each orientation is tested separately.

Why position changes the rate

Three physical effects are at work.

  • Friction. Lying flat, the balance staff spins on the tip of one pivot against a cap jewel, which is a small, smooth contact. Standing on edge, it rubs on the sides of both pivots in their hole jewels, which is more friction. The balance usually swings a little less widely in vertical positions.
  • Poise. No balance wheel is perfectly balanced. If its center of mass sits even a hair off the axis, gravity pulls that heavy spot down in the vertical positions, speeding or slowing the swing depending on where the heavy spot is and how widely the balance is swinging. Watchmakers call this poise error.
  • Hairspring behavior. The hairspring's own weight and the way it breathes can shift slightly depending on orientation.

The result is a slightly different rate in every position. See The balance wheel and hairspring.

Average rate and delta

Two numbers describe positional performance:

  • Average rate: the mean gain or loss across the positions tested.
  • Delta: the difference between the fastest and slowest positions.

A watch could have an excellent average rate of +2 seconds a day but a delta of 20 seconds, meaning it behaves very differently depending on how it's worn or stored. Another with an average of +5 and a delta of 6 is more consistent and, in daily life, often more predictable. Good regulation aims for both a small average and a small delta.

What "adjusted in five positions" means

When a movement is described as adjusted in two, three, five or six positions, it means it was regulated and checked in that many orientations at the factory. More positions means more work, tighter results and a higher price.

The ETA 2824-2, made in four grades, illustrates this well:

Grade

Positions adjusted

Average rate

Maximum variation

Standard

2

±12 seconds a day

30 seconds

Elaboré

3

±7 seconds a day

20 seconds

Top

5

±4 seconds a day

15 seconds

Chronometer

5

COSC certified

COSC limits

Certified chronometers are tested in five positions and at three temperatures. See Chronometer certification.

How positions add up on the wrist

On your wrist, a watch spends time in many positions: dial up while you type, crown down while your arm hangs at your side, somewhere in between while you walk. The rate you see each day is a blend of all of them, which is why two people wearing identical watches can see different results.

At night, though, your watch sits in one position for hours, and you can choose that position.

Use positional variance to correct your watch

This is one of the most useful tricks an owner can learn.

  1. Learn your watch's positions. Set it accurately and leave it overnight dial up. In the morning, note how many seconds it gained or lost. Over the next few nights, try dial down, crown up and crown down.
  2. Find the fast and slow positions. Most watches have at least one position that gains and one that loses or gains less.
  3. Use them at night. If your watch has been running fast on your wrist, rest it overnight in its slowest position. If it has been running slow, use its fastest. Many owners find they can keep a watch within a few seconds of the correct time for weeks this way.

The results only hold while the watch is well wound, so wear or wind it normally during the day. See Power reserve explained.

The tourbillon: a famous answer to positional error

In 1801, Abraham-Louis Breguet patented the tourbillon, which mounts the balance and escapement in a rotating cage. By turning the whole regulating system constantly, usually once a minute, it averages out the vertical positional errors of a pocket watch that spends its day upright in a waistcoat pocket. On the wrist, where a watch changes position constantly anyway, its practical benefit is smaller, but it remains one of watchmaking's most admired complications.

Positional variance and the railroad

In the age of railroad pocket watches, standards in the United States required watches to be adjusted to five positions, along with temperature and isochronism, because a train's schedule depended on every conductor's watch agreeing. The same idea, careful adjustment in several positions, still defines high-grade movements today.

How this applies to Vardesso

Where a Vardesso model uses a mechanical movement, its product page gives the movement maker's accuracy specification and, where the maker states it, the number of positions in which it is adjusted. With a few nights of observation, you can learn your own watch's positional habits and keep it closer to perfect time.

Frequently asked questions

Why does my watch gain time at night? If it rests in a position where it runs fast, such as dial up, it will gain overnight. Try another position.

Which position is best for storing a watch overnight? Whichever corrects its daytime error. There's no single best position for every watch.

What does "adjusted in five positions" mean? The movement was regulated and checked in five orientations at the factory.

Does positional variance mean something is wrong? No. Every mechanical watch has some. Large differences can be reduced by a watchmaker.

Do quartz watches have positional variance? Essentially not. The quartz crystal isn't affected by gravity the way a balance wheel is.

Does a tourbillon eliminate positional variance? It averages out vertical positional errors, but on the wrist the benefit is modest.

Keep reading

  • Regulating a watch
  • Chronometer certification
  • The balance wheel and hairspring
  • Beat rate explained
  • How a mechanical watch works, from mainspring to hands

Sources