A quartz watch runs on a battery and keeps time with a tiny quartz crystal that vibrates 32,768 times a second. A mechanical watch runs on a wound spring and keeps time with a balance wheel swinging back and forth. An automatic watch is a mechanical watch that winds itself as you wear it. Quartz wins on accuracy, convenience and price. Mechanical watches win on craftsmanship, longevity and the simple pleasure of a machine you can watch working.
This is the second lesson of the Vardesso Watch School, and the most important decision most first-time buyers make. Below is everything you need to make it well: how each type works, how accurate each really is, what each costs to own, and which one suits the way you live.
The short answer
|
|
Quartz |
Automatic |
Hand-wound mechanical |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Power source |
A battery (or light or motion in some versions) |
A mainspring, wound by a weighted rotor as you move |
A mainspring, wound by turning the crown |
|
Keeps time with |
A quartz crystal vibrating 32,768 times a second |
A balance wheel swinging, usually 6 to 8 times a second |
The same balance wheel as an automatic |
|
Typical accuracy |
About ±15 seconds a month |
About ±5 to ±20 seconds a day; certified chronometers –4/+6 |
The same as an automatic |
|
Seconds hand |
Usually ticks once a second |
Sweeps in small, quick steps |
Sweeps in small, quick steps |
|
Runs off the wrist |
Years on one battery |
Usually 38 to 80 hours, then stops |
Usually 40 to 80 hours, then needs winding |
|
Routine care |
A new battery every 2 to 5 years |
A full service roughly every 5 to 10 years |
The same, plus regular winding |
|
Best for |
Accurate, grab-and-go wear at the lowest cost |
Daily wear with mechanical character |
Ritual, slim dress watches, traditional feel |
|
Main drawback |
Less craft, and batteries to replace |
Less accurate, costlier to service |
Must be wound |
How each one works
Quartz
A quartz movement is an electronic circuit with a few gears attached. The battery sends a small current through a sliver of quartz cut into the shape of a tiny tuning fork. Quartz is piezoelectric, a property discovered by the brothers Pierre and Jacques Curie in 1880: it bends slightly when voltage is applied, and it vibrates at an extremely steady rate when kept in a circuit. Watch crystals are cut to vibrate 32,768 times a second. That number is 2 to the 15th power, so the circuit can halve it fifteen times to get exactly one pulse per second. Each pulse drives a tiny stepping motor that nudges the seconds hand forward, and a small train of gears carries the motion to the minute and hour hands.
The idea is older than most people think. Engineers Warren Marrison and J. W. Horton built the first quartz clock at Bell Telephone Laboratories in 1927. It took four decades of electronics to shrink it to wrist size: Seiko released the first quartz wristwatch, the Astron, on Christmas Day 1969. Read more in What is a quartz movement, and how does it work?
Mechanical (hand-wound)
A mechanical movement stores energy in a coiled steel spring, the mainspring, sealed inside a drum called the barrel. As the spring slowly unwinds, it turns a train of gears. Left alone, those gears would spin freely and the spring would empty in seconds. The escapement stops that from happening. A toothed escape wheel is locked and released, step by step, by a small lever called the pallet fork, which is rocked back and forth by the balance wheel. The balance, a weighted ring attached to a hair-thin spiral spring, swings back and forth at a steady rate, usually 6 or 8 times a second. Each swing lets the gears advance by one precise step, and each step pushes the balance just enough to keep it swinging. That give-and-take is the tick you hear.
Synthetic rubies, called jewels, serve as hard, smooth bearings at the points of greatest wear. To wind a hand-wound watch, you turn the crown, which turns the mainspring's arbor through a small set of gears. Read more in What is a hand-wound mechanical movement?
Automatic
An automatic, also called self-winding, is a mechanical movement with one addition: a weighted rotor, usually a half-moon of metal that pivots freely on the back of the movement. Every movement of your wrist swings the rotor, and a set of reversing wheels turns that motion into winding. When the mainspring is full, a slipping bridle lets the spring slide inside the barrel, so the watch cannot be overwound. Read more in What is an automatic watch?
The in-between options
Watchmakers have found clever ways to blend these technologies:
- Solar quartz watches charge a rechargeable cell from light, so they rarely need a battery change. See Solar-powered watches explained.
- Mecha-quartz chronographs keep time with quartz but run the stopwatch through a mechanical module. See Hybrid mecha-quartz chronograph movements.
- High-accuracy quartz compensates for temperature and can stay within a few seconds a year. See High-accuracy and thermocompensated quartz.
- Radio-controlled and GPS watches reset themselves to atomic time. See Radio-controlled and GPS time-setting watches.
- Seiko's Kinetic generated electricity from wrist motion, and Seiko's Spring Drive uses a mainspring for power but a quartz crystal to regulate a smoothly gliding seconds hand.
Accuracy, explained honestly
A standard quartz watch is typically rated to about 15 seconds a month, roughly half a second a day. A good mechanical watch is typically within about 5 seconds a day, which can add up to two or three minutes a month. That gap sounds enormous, and in raw numbers it is. Here is how the main categories compare:
|
Type |
Typical accuracy |
|---|---|
|
Vintage mechanical in good repair |
about ±15 seconds a day |
|
Modern mechanical |
about ±5 to ±10 seconds a day |
|
Certified chronometer (mechanical) |
average of –4 to +6 seconds a day in testing |
|
Seiko Spring Drive |
about ±1 second a day |
|
Standard quartz |
about ±15 seconds a month |
|
High-accuracy quartz |
about ±10 seconds a year or better |
|
Radio-controlled or GPS |
resets to atomic time, usually daily |
Why mechanical watches vary. A balance wheel is affected by gravity, so a watch runs a little differently face-up than crown-down. Temperature, how fully the mainspring is wound, magnetism and wear all play a part. A watch that runs 3 seconds fast on the wrist may run 2 seconds slow on the nightstand, and over a week the two can partly cancel out. None of this is a defect. It is the nature of a machine regulated by a swinging wheel.
What "chronometer" means. A certified chronometer has passed an independent test. Switzerland's COSC, the best-known testing body, checks each movement for about two weeks in five positions and at three temperatures, and requires an average daily rate of minus 4 to plus 6 seconds. Quartz movements can be certified too, under a far tighter standard: an average of within 0.07 seconds a day.
Why quartz drifts at all. A quartz crystal's frequency shifts slightly with temperature and, over years, with age. Standard movements accept that small drift. High-accuracy movements measure the temperature and correct for it, which is how the best reach a few seconds a year.
What it means for daily life. With a quartz watch, you may reset the time twice a year, when the clocks change. With a mechanical watch, most owners check it against their phone once a week or so and nudge it back when it is a minute out. Whether that is a chore or a pleasant habit is a matter of temperament.
Living with each one
Everyday use
- Quartz: put it on and go. Adjust for daylight saving time and, on a simple date display, at the end of any month with fewer than 31 days.
- Automatic: worn daily, it keeps itself wound. Leave it off for more than a day or two and it will stop; give the crown 20 to 30 turns, set the time and date, and put it back on. A watch winder is optional, not required.
- Hand-wound: wind it at about the same time each day, usually in the morning, until you feel the crown resist. Then stop. Many owners come to enjoy the ritual.
One tip for any mechanical watch with a date: avoid changing the date by hand in the hours around midnight, roughly 9 p.m. to 3 a.m. on most movements, when the date-changing mechanism is already engaged. Move the hands past 6 o'clock first, set the date, then set the time.
Maintenance and cost of ownership
Quartz. A battery lasts about two to five years, depending on the movement and on features such as chronographs or lights. Have a watchmaker change it rather than doing it yourself, so the case gaskets can be checked and the water resistance kept intact. Never leave a dead battery inside, since an old cell can leak and damage the circuit. Standard quartz movements are inexpensive and are often replaced outright rather than repaired.
Mechanical and automatic. Oils thicken and parts wear, so a mechanical watch needs a full service now and then: complete disassembly, cleaning, fresh lubrication, worn parts replaced, regulation and a water-resistance test. Most makers suggest a service roughly every five to ten years, and sooner if the watch starts gaining or losing noticeably. A service usually costs a few hundred dollars at an independent watchmaker and more at a luxury brand's own service center. Many popular affordable movements can simply be replaced instead, often for less.
Over a lifetime. A well-kept mechanical watch can run for generations; a watchmaker can make or adapt almost any part. A quartz watch's electronics typically last decades, and common quartz movements are easy to replace, though the exact circuit in a specialized quartz watch may eventually become hard to source.
Toughness
Quartz movements have few moving parts and shrug off the knocks of daily life. Mechanical movements are tougher than their delicacy suggests, thanks to shock-protection systems on the balance, but a hard fall can still knock one out of adjustment. Strong magnets, such as those in laptop lids, bag clasps and phone cases, can magnetize a mechanical watch's hairspring and make it run fast until a watchmaker demagnetizes it, a quick and inexpensive fix. A quartz watch may pause near a strong magnet but recovers once it is removed.
Why people still love mechanical watches
If quartz is more accurate, cheaper and easier, why do so many people pay more for mechanical? The market answers clearly. In 2019, Switzerland exported about 13.4 million electronic watches worth 3.4 billion Swiss francs, and about 7.2 million mechanical watches worth 17.1 billion. Buyers paid roughly nine times as much per watch for mechanical movements.
The reasons are human ones:
- Craft. Even a simple automatic is built from many dozens of tiny parts, many of them finished and assembled by hand. Through a clear caseback you can watch the balance swing and the rotor turn.
- Heritage. Mechanical watchmaking carries centuries of tradition, from Geneva and the Jura to Glashütte and Tokyo.
- Independence. No battery, no electronics. With occasional service, a mechanical watch can outlive its first owner and keep running for the next.
- Character. The sweeping seconds hand, the faint ticking, the slight drift you learn to know: it feels alive in a way a circuit does not.
- Attention. A mechanical watch asks a little of you, a wind in the morning or a glance to check the time. Many owners find that small daily attention a reminder that time is something to tend, not just to spend.
Why quartz deserves respect
Quartz is not the poor relation. It is the most accurate, practical way to carry the time on your wrist, and at its best it is genuinely fine watchmaking. Grand Seiko's 9F quartz movements, introduced in 1993, are assembled by hand and rated to within 10 seconds a year. Quartz made accurate watches affordable for nearly everyone on earth. For a first watch, a sports watch, a gift for a child, a watch worn only now and then, or anyone who simply wants the right time without thinking about it, quartz is often the wiser choice.
How to choose
- You want the most accurate time with no fuss: quartz, or solar quartz if you would rather never change a battery.
- You will wear one watch most days and want mechanical character: an automatic.
- You love ritual, slim dress watches or a vintage feel: a hand-wound mechanical.
- You rotate several watches: quartz or solar for the ones you wear least, since automatics stop when they sit unworn.
- Your budget is tight: quartz gets you more case and finish for the money, though good affordable automatics exist too. See The movements you'll find in most affordable watches.
- You are buying a gift: think about the recipient's habits. Someone who forgets to charge a phone may not enjoy winding a watch.
- You want an heirloom: mechanical, almost always.
Common myths
- "Quartz watches are cheap watches." Many are, but the finest quartz watches are hand-assembled and cost thousands.
- "An automatic watch is a kind of quartz watch." No. "Automatic" means a self-winding mechanical watch with no battery. A few quartz watches, such as Seiko's Kinetic, recharge from motion, but they are a different technology.
- "You can overwind an automatic." You cannot. A slipping bridle lets the mainspring slide once it is full. A hand-wound watch has a firm stop instead; just don't force the crown past it.
- "Expensive mechanical watches are more accurate than quartz." Almost never. Even a top chronometer is far less accurate than an ordinary quartz watch.
- "Quartz watches tick and mechanical watches sweep." Usually, but not always. Some high-frequency quartz watches sweep, and some mechanical watches are deliberately built to tick once a second.
How this applies to Vardesso
Every Vardesso product page states the movement type, names the exact movement, and lists its accuracy rating and its power reserve or battery life, so you can compare watches on the same terms. Use the movement filter on any collection page to see only quartz, automatic or hand-wound models.
Frequently asked questions
Which is more accurate, quartz or automatic? Quartz, by a wide margin. A typical quartz watch is accurate to about 15 seconds a month; a typical automatic to about 5 to 20 seconds a day.
Do automatic watches need batteries? No. An automatic is powered entirely by its mainspring, which your wrist motion keeps wound.
How long does an automatic watch last? With regular servicing, many decades and often generations. Mechanical watches from the early 1900s are still running today.
Is a mechanical watch worth the extra cost? If you value craft, heritage and longevity, many people think so. If you mainly want accurate time at the lowest cost, quartz is the better value.
What happens if I don't wear my automatic for a few days? It stops once the mainspring runs down, usually after 38 to 80 hours. Wind it, set the time and date, and wear it as usual. Stopping does no harm.
Do quartz watches need servicing? Mostly just batteries and a check of the gaskets. The movement itself rarely needs attention, and when it does, it is often replaced.
Which is better for a first watch? Either can be. Quartz is simpler and more forgiving. An affordable automatic is a wonderful introduction to mechanical watches if you will wear it often.
Is a hand-wound watch the same as a mechanical watch? A hand-wound watch is one kind of mechanical watch; an automatic is the other. See "Mechanical" vs "automatic": clearing up the terms.
Keep reading
- What is a quartz movement, and how does it work?
- What is an automatic watch?
- What is a hand-wound mechanical movement?
- Solar-powered watches explained
- The movements you'll find in most affordable watches
Sources
- Seiko Museum: the pursuit of accuracy and the Quartz Astron
- Guinness World Records: the first quartz clock
- Time+Tide: everything you need to know about COSC
- Chronocentric: reasonable accuracy expectations by type of watch
- Federation of the Swiss Watch Industry: export statistics by movement type
- Monochrome Watches: the history of the automatic watch
- Seiko Museum: Grand Seiko's 9F quartz and Seiko's power systems