How Accurate Should a Watch Be? Quartz and Mechanical Accuracy Explained

How Accurate Should a Watch Be? Quartz and Mechanical Accuracy Explained

A standard quartz watch should be accurate to about ±15 seconds a month. A mechanical watch is measured in seconds per day: entry-level automatic movements are typically rated around −20 to +40 seconds a day, better Swiss and Japanese movements around ±10 to ±15, and certified chronometers −4 to +6. Most well-regulated mechanical watches do better than their official tolerance. If your watch is within its movement's rating, it's working normally.

Accuracy at a glance

Type of watch

Typical accuracy

Per year, roughly

Radio-controlled or GPS

Corrects itself to the official time

Effectively exact

High-accuracy (thermocompensated) quartz

About ±5 to ±20 seconds a year; a few models ±1 second a year

Seconds

Standard quartz

About ±10 to ±20 seconds a month

Around 2 to 4 minutes

Certified chronometer (COSC)

−4 to +6 seconds a day

Minutes, if never reset

Better mechanical (for example, Swiss standard grade)

About ±12 seconds a day on average

Minutes

Entry-level mechanical (for example, Seiko NH35)

−20 to +40 seconds a day

Many minutes

The gap looks enormous on paper, and it is: even a basic quartz watch is far more accurate than the finest mechanical one. But in daily life, most mechanical owners simply reset the time every week or two, along with the date at the end of short months, and think nothing of it.

Why are quartz watches so much more accurate?

A quartz watch counts the vibrations of a tiny quartz crystal, which oscillates 32,768 times a second when an electric current passes through it. That frequency is extremely stable, and the electronics count it precisely. A mechanical watch relies on a balance wheel swinging a few times a second, powered by a spring whose force varies and affected by position, temperature, magnetism and shocks. See What is a quartz movement? and The balance wheel and hairspring.

High-accuracy quartz watches go further by measuring temperature and correcting for it, since temperature is the main source of quartz error. See High-accuracy and thermocompensated quartz.

Common movements and their official accuracy

Movement

Type

Official accuracy

Seiko NH35

Japanese automatic

−20 to +40 seconds a day

Miyota 8215

Japanese automatic

−20 to +40 seconds a day

Miyota 9015

Japanese automatic

−10 to +30 seconds a day

ETA 2824-2 / Sellita SW200-1 (standard grade)

Swiss automatic

About ±12 seconds a day on average

COSC-certified chronometer

Any certified movement

−4 to +6 seconds a day

Typical quartz

Quartz

About ±15 seconds a month

Official tolerances are deliberately wide, so they cover every movement made, in every position, at any state of wind. In practice, many entry-level automatics run within about ±10 seconds a day on the wrist, especially once regulated. See The movements you'll find in most affordable watches.

Accuracy standards and certifications

  • COSC chronometer certification: the Swiss Official Chronometer Testing Institute tests uncased movements over several days, in several positions and at three temperatures. A certified movement averages between −4 and +6 seconds a day. See Chronometer certification.
  • Brand standards: some brands test the finished, cased watch to their own tighter standards. Rolex, for example, specifies −2 to +2 seconds a day for its Superlative Chronometers, and Omega's Master Chronometers, tested with the Swiss federal institute of metrology (METAS), allow 0 to +5 seconds a day.
  • Movement grades: some Swiss movements come in grades, such as standard, elaboré, top and chronometer, each regulated to a tighter tolerance and in more positions.

What affects a mechanical watch's accuracy?

Factor

What happens

Position

A watch runs at slightly different rates dial up, dial down and crown up or down. See Positional variance.

State of wind

Many movements run differently when fully wound than near the end of their power reserve. See Power reserve explained.

Temperature

Heat and cold change the hairspring's elasticity slightly.

Magnetism

A magnetized hairspring usually makes a watch run very fast. See Watch magnetism.

Shocks

A hard knock can affect the rate or the regulation.

Age and lubrication

As oils age, accuracy and amplitude decline until the watch is serviced.

Your wearing habits

How active you are and how long you wear it each day affects its state of wind.

How to measure your watch's accuracy

You don't need special equipment:

  1. Find a reliable reference. Use an official time source, such as time.gov in the United States, or your phone's network time.
  2. Set the watch exactly to the reference, ideally using hacking to stop the seconds hand. See Hacking seconds.
  3. Check at the same time each day for a week, and note how many seconds fast or slow it is.
  4. Work out the average. Divide the total gain or loss by the number of days. If it's 21 seconds fast after 7 days, it gains 3 seconds a day.
  5. Wear it normally during the test, since accuracy on the wrist is what matters.

For a quick reading, smartphone timing apps can listen to a mechanical watch's ticking and estimate its rate, though a watchmaker's timegrapher is more reliable.

A trick for fine-tuning: overnight position

Because a mechanical watch runs at different rates in different positions, you can nudge its overall accuracy by choosing how you leave it at night. Over a few nights, note whether it gains or loses dial up, dial down, crown up and crown down. If it tends to run fast on the wrist, leave it overnight in its slowest position, and vice versa.

When should you worry about accuracy?

  • A mechanical watch suddenly gains several minutes a day: it's very likely magnetized. A watchmaker can demagnetize it quickly and inexpensively.
  • A mechanical watch runs well outside its rating: it may need regulating or a service. See Regulating a watch.
  • The rate becomes erratic after a knock or a fall: have it checked.
  • A quartz watch loses minutes or the seconds hand jumps in two-second steps: the battery is probably running low.
  • A quartz watch gains or loses more than a minute or so a month: something may be wrong with the movement.

Fast or slow: which is better?

Most people prefer a mechanical watch that runs slightly fast. Being a few minutes early is better than being late, and because many movements slow down near the end of their power reserve, a slight gain helps balance that out.

How this applies to Vardesso

Each Vardesso product page names the movement, so you can look up its official accuracy. If your watch runs outside that specification while it's under warranty, contact us first, since having it opened elsewhere may affect your coverage.

Questions and answers

How accurate should a quartz watch be?

About ±10 to ±20 seconds a month for a standard quartz watch; high-accuracy quartz can be within seconds a year.

How accurate should an automatic watch be?

It depends on the movement. Entry-level automatics are typically rated −20 to +40 seconds a day; better movements around ±10 to ±15; chronometers −4 to +6.

Is +10 seconds a day good for an automatic watch?

Yes. It's well within the rating of most automatic movements.

Is gaining 1 minute a day normal for a mechanical watch?

No. That's outside most movements' ratings. The usual cause is magnetism; a watchmaker can check and fix it.

Why do mechanical watches lose or gain time?

Their rate changes with position, temperature, state of wind, magnetism and shocks, and as oils age.

What is the most accurate type of watch?

Radio-controlled and GPS watches, which correct themselves to official time. Among self-contained watches, thermocompensated quartz is the most accurate.

What does COSC certified mean?

The movement passed the Swiss Official Chronometer Testing Institute's accuracy tests, averaging −4 to +6 seconds a day.

How do I check my watch's accuracy?

Set it to an official time source, check it at the same time each day for a week, and divide the total difference by the number of days.

Can a watchmaker make my watch more accurate?

Yes. Regulating a mechanical movement can bring its rate closer to zero, within the limits of the movement.

Why is my automatic watch running fast?

The most common cause of a sudden, large gain is magnetism. Small gains are normal and can depend on position and wearing habits.

Why is my automatic watch running slow?

It may not be fully wound, the oils may be aging, or the movement may need regulating. Wear it a full day or wind it, and check again.

Does temperature affect watch accuracy?

Yes, slightly, for both quartz and mechanical watches. Thermocompensated quartz movements correct for it.

How often should I set a mechanical watch?

Most owners reset the time every week or two, or whenever it drifts far enough to bother them.

Is a quartz watch more accurate than an automatic?

Yes, by a wide margin. Even an inexpensive quartz watch is far more accurate than most mechanical watches.

Keep reading

  • Quartz vs automatic vs mechanical: the complete guide
  • Chronometer certification
  • Positional variance
  • Regulating a watch
  • Watch magnetism

Sources