Polishing a watch removes a thin layer of metal to take out scratches, and that metal can never be put back. Repeated polishing softens edges, thins lugs and can blur engraving and finishing. On a modern watch you wear daily, one careful, professional polish can be reasonable. On a vintage or collectible watch, most experts advise against it.
What does polishing actually do?
Polishing is not cleaning. A polisher abrades the surface with progressively finer compounds until the scratch disappears, which means the surface has to be cut down to the depth of the deepest scratch first. That removes metal from the case, lugs, bezel and sometimes the bracelet. Estimates of how much one pass takes off vary from case to case, but it is measurable, and it adds up with each repeat.
Side effects of heavy polishing include:
- Softened edges. Sharp bevels, crisp lug edges and the line between brushed and polished surfaces become rounded.
- Thinner lugs and case. Over time, the watch can look and feel slimmer, and a bracelet can fit looser.
- Lost details. Engravings, hallmarks, serial numbers and markings on a bezel can be thinned or lost.
- Changed finish. A brushed surface turns shiny unless it is carefully re-finished.
- Heat and debris. Polishing creates heat and metal dust, so the movement is normally removed from the case first.
Brushed and polished surfaces catch light differently, so a refinished area is easy to spot beside the original finish if it isn't blended carefully.
What are the arguments for polishing?
- A watch you wear every day collects marks, and a good refinish can make it look fresh.
- A single light, professional polish on a modern watch is considered acceptable by many dealers.
- The pleasure of wearing a watch you love looking at is a valid reason.
What are the arguments against?
- It's irreversible. Once metal is gone, only welding metal back can restore it, which is rarely done.
- Collectors prize originality. For vintage and collectible watches, a case with its original sharp lines is usually valued more highly than a polished one, and the common collector advice is never to polish a vintage watch.
- It repeats. If you polish every few years, you thin the case each time.
- Skill varies. An inexperienced polisher can leave uneven surfaces or blurred lines.
- Scratches are part of a watch's story, for many owners, and they often become less noticeable over time.
Opinions differ, and neither side is wrong. It depends on the watch, what you plan to do with it and how much the marks bother you.
When can polishing make sense?
- The watch is a modern, daily-wear piece you intend to keep and use.
- The case is heavily scratched and the marks really bother you.
- You are using a professional who preserves the original shapes and finishes, and who will tell you if it isn't a good idea.
- You accept that it's permanent.
When should you avoid it?
- The watch is vintage, rare or sentimental in its original state.
- The case has been polished before.
- You plan to sell the watch and its originality may matter to buyers.
- The watch has fine details near the surface, such as a tachymeter bezel, engraved markings or sharp bevels.
- The case has a coating, or is made of a material that polishes differently from steel.
- You're thinking of doing it yourself with a rotary tool or buffing wheel.
What are the alternatives?
- Leave the marks. Many owners decide that scratches show a watch has been used.
- A service without refinishing. When you send a watch for service, you can ask the workshop in writing not to polish the case.
- Careful light cleaning, which removes dirt that looks like marks. Our article on how to clean a watch at home covers it.
- A replacement crystal, if the damage is to the crystal rather than the case. A watchmaker can advise.
- Preventing new marks. A simple habit such as taking the watch off for heavy work helps.
Be wary of products and cloths that promise to remove scratches. Some are fine for light marks on certain finishes, but any abrasive acts like a polish, and a heavy hand can leave you with the effects above.
What should you tell a workshop?
When you drop off a watch for service, say clearly, and in writing, whether you want the case polished. Some workshops include refinishing by default, and a service doesn't need to include polishing. Ask what is included in the quote before agreeing.
How this applies to Vardesso watches
How a Vardesso watch's case is finished, and how it responds to refinishing, depends on the model, so check the product page or contact Vardesso before you have any case refinished. If your watch is under any warranty or service arrangement, ask before polishing or any other cosmetic work.
Questions and answers
Should I polish my watch?
Only if you accept that it permanently removes metal. For a modern watch you wear daily, one careful professional polish can be reasonable. For vintage or collectible watches, most experts advise against it.
Does polishing devalue a watch?
Opinions vary. Collectors generally prefer original, unpolished cases, particularly on vintage watches, while a single light polish on a modern watch is often seen as acceptable. Treat resale effects as uncertain.
Does polishing remove metal?
Yes. It cuts the surface down below the deepest scratch, and the metal is gone for good.
How often can a watch be polished?
There's no safe number. Each polish thins the case, so fewer is better.
Can I polish a watch myself?
It's not recommended. A buffing wheel or rotary tool can round edges and blur finishes quickly, and heat and debris can harm the movement.
Can scratches be removed without polishing?
Light surface marks can sometimes be reduced with careful cleaning. Real scratches in the metal need abrasion, which is polishing.
Can sapphire crystal scratches be polished out?
Sapphire is extremely hard and isn't a home job. A damaged crystal is usually replaced.
Can acrylic crystal scratches be polished out?
Often, yes, with a suitable polish, which is a traditional fix for acrylic. A watchmaker can do it or advise.
Does polishing affect water resistance?
The case must be opened and the movement removed for proper polishing, so seals need replacing and the watch needs testing afterwards.
Does a service include polishing?
Not necessarily. Some workshops do it by default, so ask for it to be left out if you don't want it.
Should I polish a vintage watch?
Usually not. Collectors value original, unpolished cases, and the effect can't be undone.
Can polishing be reversed?
Not in practice. Metal can be welded back on, but this is specialist work and is rarely done.
How do I keep my watch from getting scratched?
Take it off for heavy work, avoid knocking it against hard surfaces and store it separately from other watches and hard objects.
Keep reading
- How to Clean a Watch at Home (/blogs/watch-care/how-to-clean-a-watch-at-home)
- What Happens During a Watch Service? (/blogs/watch-care/what-happens-during-a-watch-service)
- How Often Should a Watch Be Serviced? (/blogs/watch-care/how-often-to-service-a-watch)
- Gaskets and Pressure Testing (/blogs/watch-care/watch-gaskets-and-pressure-testing)
- Watch Casebacks Explained (/blogs/watch-basics/watch-casebacks-explained)
- Anatomy of a Watch (/blogs/watch-basics/anatomy-of-a-watch)